Advertisement

Header Utility Menu

  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Events

LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram Get Our App

  • Login

Virginia Business

Mobile Menu

  • Issues
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finances
    • Law
    • Real Estate
    • Economic Development
    • Education
    • Energy/Green
    • Federal Contracting
    • Government
    • Healthcare
    • Hotels/Tourism
    • Insurance
    • Ports/Trade
    • Small Business
    • Technology
    • Transportation
  • Regions
    • Central Virginia
    • Eastern Virginia
    • Northern Virginia
    • Roanoke/New River Valley
    • Shenandoah Valley
    • Southern Virginia
    • Southwest Virginia
  • Reports
    • Best Places to Work
    • Business Person of the Year
    • CEO Pay
    • COVID-19
    • Generous Virginians Project
    • Legal Elite
    • Most Influential Virginians
    • Maritime Guide
    • Site Locator
    • The Big Book
    • Virginia CFO Awards
  • Company News
    • For the Record
    • People
  • Opinion
  • Lists
  • Awards/Events
    • Power Up Virginia 500
    • Women in Leadership
    • Diversity Leadership Series
    • Virginia 500
    • Legal Elite
    • CFO Awards
    • Big Book of Lists
    • 100 People To Meet
    • Best Places To Work
  • Virginia 500
    • Power Up Virginia 500
    • Read The Issue
    • Order a copy
    • Buy an award plaque
    • Suggest execs for 2022

Advertisement

Header Primary Menu

  • Issues
    • August 2022
    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • May 2022
    • April 2022
    • Issues Archive
  • Industries
    • Banking/Finances
    • Law
    • Real Estate
    • Economic Development
    • Education
    • Energy/Green
    • Federal Contracting
    • Government
    • Healthcare
    • Hotels/Tourism
    • Insurance
    • Ports/Trade
    • Small Business
    • Technology
    • Transportation
  • Regions
    • Central Virginia
    • Eastern Virginia
    • Northern Virginia
    • Roanoke/New River Valley
    • Shenandoah Valley
    • Southern Virginia
    • Southwest Virginia
  • Reports
    • Best Places to Work
    • Business Person of the Year
    • CEO Pay
    • COVID-19
    • Generous Virginians Project
    • Legal Elite
    • Most Influential Virginians
    • Maritime Guide
    • Site Locator
    • The Big Book
    • Virginia CFO Awards
  • Company News
    • For the Record
    • People
  • Opinion
  • Lists
  • Awards/Events
    • Power Up Virginia 500
    • Women in Leadership
    • Diversity Leadership Series
    • Virginia 500
    • Legal Elite
    • CFO Awards
    • Big Book of Lists
    • 100 People To Meet
    • Best Places To Work
  • Virginia 500
    • Power Up Virginia 500
    • Read The Issue
    • Order a copy
    • Buy an award plaque
    • Suggest execs for 2022

Home Opinion Our View Employee reviews – passé and in the way of better results

Employee reviews – passé and in the way of better results

Published September 29, 2015 by Bernie Niemeier

Photo by Mark Rhodes

The home stretch of 2015 is here.  As business begins in the fourth quarter, thoughts naturally drift toward the year’s accomplishments.  For most managers and employees, this likely includes individual performance assessments.

Often dreaded and anxiety inducing for everyone involved, annual reviews became a business staple in the 1960s and 1970s as corporations scaled up, creating conglomerates through mergers and acquisitions.

Performance reviews were viewed as helpful in managing significantly larger numbers of employees.  This also led to the ascendency of bigger, more powerful human resources departments.

Throughout business history many have worked to improve these reviews.  I certainly have.  As a younger, more analytically focused manager, I tried just about everything from basic management by objectives, to five-point scales, to values-based assessments, peer-to-peer ratings and 360-reviews.  Nothing really ever seemed to work very well.

Apparently, I’m not alone in this experience. According to a late-2014 National Public Radio story, most human resources departments give even their own review process below-average marks for effectiveness. And Samuel Culbert,  a UCLA management  professor, has gone as far as to label employee reviews as “fraudulent, bogus and dishonest.”  In the pages of The Wall Street Journal, Culbert called them, “One-sided forms of employee intimidation that breed defensiveness and tension.”

On hearing this, I decided to toss out Virginia Business’ review process.  The staff heaved a sigh of relief.

Our handbook now reads, “Reviews are stressful, time consuming and counterproductive to more regular communications concerning job skills.”  It goes on to note that each employee receives ongoing feedback from supervisors, peers and customers and that we should all seek to cultivate a culture of “active mutual support.”

Problem solved?  Kind of. Like any other company we still deal with occasional performance problems.  I’m hopeful that this approach allows us to handle issues a little more effectively with less procrastination while waiting for an arbitrary review date.  And maybe, just maybe, we are an even better place to work.

Again, we’re not alone.  According to one study cited by The Washington Post, 6 percent of Fortune 500 companies have done away with employee rankings. Accenture has announced that it will do away with once-a-year evaluations in 2016. Other large companies, such as Microsoft, Adobe and Deloitte, have eliminated or dramatically simplified their reviews.

Reducing tension and defensiveness at work sounds like an opportunity. What should take the place of effort devoted to annual reviews?  How about more time spent listening to customers?  It’s always good to get outside of the building and see what’s happening in the marketplace.

Lately, we’ve been conducting business roundtables. This includes one with businesses in Northern Virginia hosted by the Fairfax County Economic Development Authority.   In September, we held our annual Economic Expectations Roundtable, hosted by the Virginia Society of CPAs.  Just a few days ago, we sat down with several commercial real estate executives to discuss trends.  Coming up in November, we’ll host the annual Virginia Business Political Roundtable.

All of these sessions are designed to keep our editors in touch with business executives.  This translates into better content for readers and ultimately develops an increasingly effective audience for advertisers.

So if you aren’t happy with your company’s performance reviews, maybe it’s time to redirect that time and energy into more customer-facing activity.  You won’t be alone.  In fact, you’ll be in good company.  You might even be rewarded with better results.  Go for it!

For more on these and related topics in Virginia Business:

  • Best Places to Work in Virginia
  • Work/Life Balance
  • Economic Expectations Roundtable —  coming in November issue.
  • Virginia Business Political Roundtable — coverage of our Nov. 11 event will appear in the January 2016 issue.

Related Stories

Virginia Business logo

The end of innocence

Virginia Business logo

Predictable results – the incumbents, of course!

Virginia Business logo

Making business more attractive – part two

Trending

Va. Beach honors Ramon W. Breeden Jr.

Caesars ups Danville casino investment to $650M

CarLotz to merge with San Francisco’s Shift

Restoration Bioproducts to build $5.8M biochar plant

Axios to be sold to Cox Enterprises for $525M

Sponsored Stories

Creating An Urban Destination in Chesapeake

5 surprising facts employers should know about voluntary benefits

What Supply Chain Problems should you be planning for in 2023?

Advertisement

Advertisement

Trending

Va. Beach honors Ramon W. Breeden Jr.

Caesars ups Danville casino investment to $650M

CarLotz to merge with San Francisco’s Shift

Restoration Bioproducts to build $5.8M biochar plant

Axios to be sold to Cox Enterprises for $525M

Sponsored Stories

Creating An Urban Destination in Chesapeake

5 surprising facts employers should know about voluntary benefits

What Supply Chain Problems should you be planning for in 2023?

Get Virginia Business directly on your tablet or in your mailbox!

Subscribe to Virginia Business

Advertisement

Advertisement

Footer Primary Menu

  • virginiabusiness.com
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Footer Secondary Menu

  • Industries
  • Regions
  • Reports
  • Company News
  • Events

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Sign Up

LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram Get Our App

Privacy Policy Cookie Policy

Footer Utility Menu

Copyright © 2022 Virginia Business. All rights reserved.

Site Maintained by TechArk